Cocoa Varieties Explained

Not all cocoa is the same. For buyers, manufacturers, and formulators, it is important to understand the different cocoa bean varieties. Different cocoa species give different cocoa flavors and other product characteristics. In this article we'll discuss the most common cocoa varieties and how this may impact your business and buying decisions.

Cocoa Tree Varieties

All commercial cacao beans, including Criollo, Forastero, and Trinitario, come from the same species: Theobroma cacao. The key is in the genetic differences within the species. Just like apples, grapes, or tomatoes, a single plant species can have many varieties (or cultivars) that show very different traits.

Commercial Cocoa Types

The global trade of cocoa and chocolate is led by three main cocoa types: Criollo, Forastero, and Trinitario. Each type has its own strengths and weaknesses. Knowing these differences helps buyers choose the right source based on quality, price, and how they plan to use it.

Criollo

Criollo is the rarest and most delicate type of cocoa. It is known for its low bitterness, floral smell, and rich flavor. This cocoa is mostly used in high-quality chocolate. However, Criollo trees do not produce much cocoa and are prone to diseases, making them hard to find and expensive. This type of cocoa is mainly grown in Venezuela, Peru, Nicaragua, and Madagascar, and is often labeled as "fine flavor." Criollo is thought to make up about 1-5% of the world's cocoa production. Some estimates suggest it could be as low as 0.01%.

Used for: Premium chocolate, bean-to-bar production, specialty markets.

Forastero

Forastero cocoa accounts for about 80-85% of the world's cocoa production. It is a tough and productive type that grows well in various climates and resists diseases. This quality makes it ideal for large farms. Its flavor is stronger, more bitter, and simpler, which is why it is commonly used in mass-market chocolate, cocoa powder, and industrial products.

Used for: Bulk chocolate, cocoa powder, industrial food applications

Trinitario

Trinitario is a natural mix of Criollo and Forastero cocoa beans. It was developed after a disease outbreak in Trinidad in the 18th century. This hybrid has the great taste of Criollo and the strong, high-yield qualities of Forastero. This makes it a good choice for both producers and buyers. Trinitario is mainly grown in the Caribbean, Latin America, and parts of Southeast Asia. It is often considered fine or flavor cocoa in premium markets.

Used for: High-quality chocolate, specialty blends, bean-to-bar production

Cocoa Origins

Cocoa comes from many different places, each with its own types. It mostly grows in areas near the Equator. The main producers of cocoa are West Africa, Latin America, and Southeast Asia. The special climate and soil in these regions help create the unique flavors and qualities of cocoa beans.

1. West Africa: West African cocoa has strong flavors. It is the most produced type of cocoa. Countries like Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana lead in this market and supply a large part of the world's cocoa.
2. Latin America: This region has many different flavors, including fruity, floral, nutty, and spicy. Countries such as Ecuador and Peru are well-known for their high-quality cocoa beans, which are often used in premium chocolate.
3. Southeast Asia: This region is not well-known for making chocolate, but its cocoa beans are getting attention for their special flavors. Malaysia and Indonesia are important in this market, providing beans that have unique traits.

Cocoa Organizations

• The International Cocoa Organization (ICCO) is a group made up of different governments that keeps an eye on cocoa markets, sets standards, and identifies high-quality cocoa origins.
• The World Cocoa Foundation (WCF) is a non-profit organization that works with the industry to promote sustainability, improve farmers' lives, and build resilience to climate change. It unites leading chocolate companies to help make lasting improvements in cocoa supply chains.
• Cocoa Horizons, started by Barry Callebaut in 2015, provides a clear way to source cocoa sustainably. It focuses on tracking cocoa origins, helping local communities, and considering the environment. This program is commonly used in private label and industrial chocolate production.
• Certifications like Fairtrade and Rainforest Alliance are also widely used, particularly in retail-focused products. They provide buyers with verified claims related to ethical labor practices, fair pricing, and sustainable farming methods.

These programs help buyers navigate the growing demand for transparency, impact reporting, and responsibly sourced cocoa.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What are the three main varieties of cocoa?

The three primary cocoa varieties are Forastero, Criollo, and Trinitario. Nacional is sometimes considered a fourth variety but is much rarer.

What is the best variety of cacao?

Criollo is often considered the best cacao variety due to its complex flavor profile and low bitterness. Nacional is also highly valued for its floral aroma, though it is far less common.

How to identify Criollo cacao?

Criollo beans are light in color, often white or pale purple. They have thinner pods with a smoother texture and produce a mild, less bitter chocolate with floral undertones.

Which country has the best cacao in the world?

Venezuela and Ecuador are often recognized for having the best cacao, with Venezuela known for Criollo varieties and Ecuador for its rare Nacional cacao.

How many cacao varieties are there?

There are four main cacao varieties: Forastero, Criollo, Trinitario, and Nacional. Forastero is the most common, while Criollo and Nacional are the rarest.

‍